Whenever a cell phone is introduced to the market (and sometimes before it’s even out), the web gets swamped with reviews of all sorts. There is a constant competition to bring out the informative, comprehensive review that helps the consumer decide if he or she is willing to invest or not. Analysts who beat the crowd in offering a quality review consequently drive immense traffic to their website or blog, and their visitors exponentially boom as they show up in high positions in search-engine results. I was interested in analyzing the performance and reliability months after purchasing Nokia’s E71, because that is the real measurement of how successful the product is.
I purchased the Nokia E71 around New Year’s, and have been heavily relying on it ever since. Looking back, things seem very different than when I first chose to make the investment. To start off, let’s look back at what was said or reviewed when the iPhone 3G competitor hit the shelves:
- Nokia’s official webste (for reference, not opinion)
- The Boy Genius Report review
- The Engadget Mobile review
- The All About Symbian review
To summarize what everyone agreed on at the time:
- Design: Sexy as hell
- Size/Weight: Small, slim, sleek
- Screen: Good quality, OK size
- Keyboard: After getting used to it, very efficient
- Connectivity: Offers everything you need (wifi, bluetooth, etc.)
- Sound: Crisp and clear
- Battery: Outstanding
- Camera: Not great, but gets the job done
Mainly, it was the phone that meets all of your needs. You can use it to organize your appointments, place reminders, use the office applications to open and edit documents, install software and further functionality and much more.
The sad but true story is that after owning the phone for a while, even if it was as revolutionary as Che Guevara when it came out, your appreciation towards what used to be strong points inevitably deflates. That is only normal. Subjectively, the following are the initial advantages that turned sour with time:
- Screen: After a while, you came to realize that the display is simply way too small. It is difficult to view any sort of image or video effectively. Besides, going through numbers or writing an email is quite the challenge, let alone editing an office document
- Keyboard: I’ll admit I don’t treat my cell phone like a girlfriend, but I still keep it relatively protected. However, the letter “z” fell off, and I keep relying on using a key to door push the button when it’s absolutely necessary (I’d change it, but I’m currently in Paris and they still believe that they have the right to stick to the AZERTY keyboards. Even if they had QWERTY keyboards, they wouldn’t have the Arabic alphabet, thus I’ll have to wait until I’m back in Cairo). It’s relatively easy to type, but I still cannot get the grip on using “shift” and the “function” button (the one that allows you to type numbers or punctuations). You’d think I would get comfortable with that by now
- Connectivity: It is very easy to fool yourself into thinking that you will be connecting with Bluetooth regularly. The fact of the matter is that it’s a number of buttons away, and eats up the battery. Added to the fact that the screen isn’t ideal for viewing images or documents anyway, it’s become somewhat impractical. The wifi is slow, just like with any portable device. Only whenever there’s a long wifi key (the typical default password that comes with new routers) it repeatedly fails to connect
- Sound: After one trip to the beach, and for a period of at least a month, the sound would randomly become bizarre. It would become distorted and very distanced. A couple of months later, however, it went back to normal
- Camera: Honestly, I would’ve rather payed $100 less and not had a camera at all. It has been completely useless. Between the horrible quality, the small screen, and the limited storage (no one’s willing to keep changing Micro SD cards), it has become a waste of space
- Calendar & ToDos: After the first week, I did not use it once. It is not intuitive and seems like a bit of a hassle. Perhaps there are people who would argue that they rely on it, but personally, I don’t use the E71 for the organization of any appointments or tasks
- GPS: The map that ships in is somewhat sluggish. But then again, that also depends on the network you are on. Either way, the screen is too small to be able to comfortably navigate with maps (no to mention that in a place like Egypt, the maps are far from complete or accurate)
Moreover, I rarely use it to listen to music (needs special earphones, the protective sponge around the ear plug’s very sharp edges have fallen off, making it a painful experience to listen to music!). The worst of all is that, after that one trip to the sandy beach, the keyboard gets stuck sometimes typing away random letters and numbers, making it impossible to send any SMS. This problem comes and goes, but thankfully, hasn’t popped up in a while. The issue should completely cease to exist upon changing the keyboard for a new one.
There are a couple of advantages that have held strong, standing out even more:
- Battery: Surprisingly enough, the battery still lasts for up to four days! With constant phone calls and internet usage, it still lives for up to 2.5 days. Something that has saved a lot of hassle
- Email: It remains an easy and efficient way to view and reply to emails. This also relies on the rates by the telecommunication providers, but that aside, communication is generally easy
- Fring: Depending on the speed and quality of the 3G network you are using, the E71 allows you to make VOIP calls using your skype account and credit. This can be achieved via Fring, a free software that runs natively on Symbian and is (generally) easy to use
It is easy to overestimate the value of a given product, and it is even easier to overlook the negative possibilities that lie ahead. Looking back, albeit with hindsight, I would say that the Nokia E71 has somewhat disappointed, but continues to be a successful investment. However, I would not recommend purchasing the E71 if any of the following apply:
- You do not have access to accessories and parts: Some things are bound to fail, and it is easy and cheap to replace them. However, without access to a store that could do that for you, the value of the mobile phone somewhat deteriorates
- You would like to constantly listen to music: The media player is not intuitive, and the headphones that come with it do not last very long. You are better off with an iPhone 3G or something more media-oriented
- Office documents are vital: Not the most efficient of phones when it comes to dealing with Word, Excel and Powerpoint documents.
If none of the previous points apply to you, baring in mind that over time, some advantages deteriorate, the E71 might be a wise choice. All in all, it is important to note that a good 40% of the features that ship with the cell phone will not be used at any point in time. While they do not consume much space, and do not interfere, they inevitably pressure you into thinking that the E71 is the appropriate choice thanks to the increased functionality. If you are looking for a cell phone that is small and light, relatively cheap, displays email and web pages, and has a very respectable battery, the Nokia E71 becomes an evident choice. Otherwise, the market does not stop bringing forward competitors of all sorts, you’ll certainly find your match.